A workers’ compensation hearing can sound intimidating, especially if you have never been involved in a legal proceeding before. But California workers’ comp hearings are not the same as a traditional civil courtroom trial, and not every hearing involves testimony or ends with the judge issuing an immediate decision.
For San Diego first responders, a hearing may involve disputes over whether an injury is compensable, disability benefits, medical issues, work restrictions, or other unresolved parts of the claim.
Our workers’ compensation attorneys in SD prepare you for what to expect, organize the issues that need to be addressed, and represent your position before the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board.

What happens at a workers’ comp hearing?
It depends on what type of hearing has been scheduled. A workers’ compensation case may first be set for a Mandatory Settlement Conference (MSC). At the conference, the parties appear before a workers’ compensation judge and discuss the disputed issues. One purpose is to determine whether the case can be resolved without going to trial.
If the parties cannot reach an agreement, the remaining issues are identified, and the case may be scheduled for trial. California DWC explains that testimony is not normally taken at a conference. A trial, on the other hand, can involve witness testimony, documents, medical reports, and other evidence before the judge makes a decision.
What happens at a Mandatory Settlement Conference?
An MSC is largely about defining the dispute and determining whether the parties can resolve it. The judge may discuss the issues with both sides and encourage settlement. If no agreement is reached, the parties generally identify the matters that still need to be decided and the evidence or witnesses they intend to rely on at trial.
That can include disagreements about:
- Whether the injury is work-related
- Temporary or permanent disability
- Wage or benefit calculations
- Medical evidence
- Work restrictions
- Other benefits or disputed parts of the claim
For a first responder, the dispute may also involve issues specific to public safety employment, such as salary continuation or occupational presumptions. The conference is important even when the case does not settle because it helps define what will actually be contested at trial.
What happens if my case goes to trial?
A California workers’ compensation trial takes place before a workers’ compensation judge, not a jury. At trial, the parties can present the evidence needed to support their positions. That may include medical reports, employment records, payroll information, other documents, and witness testimony. California WCAB rules require the parties to bring the evidence necessary to prove their claim or defense.
You may also be asked to testify about matters such as how the injury occurred, your job duties, symptoms, treatment, work restrictions, or another disputed fact. The judge considers the evidence and arguments and later issues a written decision. DWC notes that the decision is typically sent after trial rather than announced immediately in the hearing room.
Do I have to attend the workers’ comp hearing?
You should assume that your attendance is required unless your attorney or the WCAB tells you otherwise. California WCAB rules require parties to appear, or have an attorney or other authorized representative appear, at hearings involving the main case unless the appearance has been excused. DWC also warns that failing to attend a required conference or hearing can delay the case and, in some circumstances, create more serious problems.

Which workers’ compensation attorneys in SD have experience representing first responders at a hearing?
First responders serving Shelltown and communities across San Diego deserve to know what is coming before they walk into a WCAB proceeding. Our attorneys prepare your case, organize the evidence, explain your role, address the disputed issues, and represent your position through conferences, trial, and other stages that may require a formal appearance.
A hearing is only one part of the broader claim process. Understanding how long a claim can take from filing to decision and what to do after a workers’ comp claim is denied can help you see how each stage fits together. Schedule a free consultation with our team, and we’ll help you prepare for the proceeding, understand what is at stake, and move into the next stage of your claim with a clear plan.

